Pin Grading Guide

Enamel Pin Perfection: Handcrafted Uniqueness

Every enamel pin is meticulously filled and polished by hand, giving each one a unique charm. Due to the handmade nature, you may notice slight variations or tiny defects from pin to pin. Embrace these quirks as a part of their handcrafted beauty!

Despite these nuances, I personally inspect and sort every pin before it ships out, ensuring a consistent standard of quality for everyone.

Our Pin Grades:

Standard Pins (A-Grade)

Our top-tier pins may feature minor cosmetic imperfections, a testament to their handmade origin. Possible imperfections include:

  • Small buff marks or scuffs on the metal/enamel
  • Minor metal discoloration
  • Tiny specks on the enamel surface or inside epoxy
  • Slight plating inconsistencies

Seconds Pins (B-Grade)

These pins have more noticeable flaws and are offered at a discount. Possible imperfections include:

  • Smudges or staining
  • Trapped lint
  • Small unfilled areas
  • Noticeable scratches on metal and enamel
  • Heavy metal oxidation
  • Specks or pores in enamel
  • Bent posts/backings
  • Uneven epoxy surfaces
  • Small air bubbles in epoxy

Unsellable Pins (C-Grade)

Pins with significant flaws, available only upon request at a deep discount. Possible imperfections include:

  • Loose posts/backings
  • Major unfilled areas
  • Incorrect color placement
  • Overfilled enamel
  • Missing epoxy areas

If you have any questions about the pins or their quality, please don't hesitate to reach out! I’m always happy to provide photo samples to ensure you receive the perfect pin.